Good advice, right?
Financial stocks are, once again, the scourge of Wall Street. There is talk of new financial regulation, rumors that the big banks will be broken up and sold, criminal investigations, and concerns about bad debts in Europe - all of which are making headlines daily. Will the horrors never end?
Professional money managers have been busy writing articles with frightening headlines, warning you that financial stocks are dangerous and to avoid them "at all costs." Yet, at the same time as they have been telling you to stay clear, they have been buying a lot for themselves.
Institutional ownership of Bank of America is 56%, Wells Fargo 75%, Morgan Stanley 75%, and Goldman Sachs 72%. For comparison, institutional ownership of Wal-Mart is 36%, Exxon 49%, Proctor and Gamble 58%, and General Electric 50%. If you want to have some real fun, go to the disclosure section of any article that tells you to sell stocks, and check the author’s holdings. You may find that while the author is telling you to sell certain stocks, the disclosure reveals that he owns them all. So yes, he does indeed want you to sell your stocks - so that he can buy them from you.
Here are the major reasons why financial institutions are set to outperform long-term:
The U.S. housing market In 2008 and 2009, the price of real estate was plummeting, taking the net worth of the average American down with it. But prices have now stabilized, and at extremely low levels. The painful de-leveraging of America is over. The U.S. now has some of the most affordable housing in the industrialized world, and it won’t stay that way forever.
Client PurgesIn the previous two years, numerous clients of major banks received letters telling them, for example, that their line of credit would be cancelled if they did not use it within the next 90 days. Clients were outraged, and many cancelled their cards just out of spite - which is was exactly what the banks wanted. This was money that the banks could have been lending out for a profit, but that was instead locked into credit with customers who would never use it. The banks, from their perspective, got rid of a lot of dead weight. They also got rid of a lot of credit risk.
RestructuringDuring the height of the financial crisis, the industry was shedding 39,000 jobs every month. Although layoffs can hurt good employees as well as bad, it can safely be said that the best, brightest and most necessary were not the first to go. In addition to the widespread layoffs, many financial institutions streamlined their processes, eliminated business segments not related to their core business, and just generally refocused. The financial industry is leaner and hungrier than it has been in a very long time.
Solid balance sheetsThe balance sheets of U.S. financials have been heavily scrutinized by investors, the SEC, the government, hedge funds, and the Federal Reserve. Tier 1 Capital ratios (measures of bank safety) are well above normal. Citigroup, generally considered one of the weakest, has a Tier 1 capital ratio of 11.92% - almost double the level necessary to be called "well-capitalized." In addition, many banks are sitting on extraordinary amounts of cash and have large loan loss reserves.
Financial ReformThe proposed financial reform legislation is often portrayed as a capitalism killer in the conservative media, but it is nothing of the sort. The bill proposes larger capital requirements for those who take more risks, greater transparency in general, and a federal body for winding down companies that nonetheless fail. In other words, large financial institutions will be more subject to scrutiny, require more fallback as their risk levels climbs, and if they fail their operations will be wound down in a manner that is least disruptive to markets and paid for by the industry itself (not taxpayers). Accountability makes for good capitalism.
ValuationsMany financial institutions belong in the single digit forward P/E club. JP Morgan has a forward P/E ratio of 8.2; Goldman Sachs 7.0; Morgan Stanley 7.5, and Citibank 8.9. Citi also has $5.61 of book value per share. Imagine if someone came up to you and said, "I'll sell you this genuine $5 bill for $4 dollars." You would probably assume it was fake, since in the real world this never happens. In the world of Wall Street, however, it happens all the time. At the moment, you can buy $5.61 worth of Citibank assets for $3.81, and get all their clients, brand names, and worldwide businesses for free: Morgan Stanley, Bank of America, MetLife, Travelers, Capital One, and many others are the same.
For small investors to get significant coverage in the financial industry, you need only buy two exchange traded funds - the XLF (large institutions) and the KRE (regional banks). Due to the present worldwide housing bubble, I recommend buying mostly regional banks (KRE) first, until the full brunt of International problems hit their markets (in the short term, psychology trumps value every time). But for value investors, buying time is now.
Statistics (at time of writing):
KRE $27.32
XLF $15.35
____
“You can’t make a baby in one month by getting nine women pregnant.”Warren Buffett, 2009, explaining the importance of investment patience.
____
Disclosure and Disclaimer
I own all companies listed here as individual stocks, in ETFs, or both.
Do not buy stocks, or take this or any other financial advice without doing your own analysis; including, but not limited to: reviewing business models, financial statements, management style and philosophy, recent developments, market macroeconomic analysis, and chart analysis. If you do not know how to do these things, you shouldn't be buying stocks in the first place. Seek the advice of professionals, as appropriate.
