Worldwide Business Search Engine

Loading

Sunday, November 20, 2011

Are Hedge Funds Safe?



Many people now regard hedge funds as an alternative to mutual funds.  Marketed as the “rich man’s mutual fund,” hedge funds are supposed to be safer than mutual funds but with higher returns.  Is it true?

In the past, most hedge funds hedged.  That is, hedge funds positioned themselves so that whether the markets went up or down, they would make small but consistent returns.  One strategy, for example, was to buy stocks, but also buy put options on those stocks in case the market dropped (put options go up in value if stocks drop).  The end result would be a slightly lower return than the general market in boom times, but also a small return in panic times – overall, a small return that is more reliable and steadier than the market.  But that is the past.

These days, virtually all hedge funds make money from extreme leverage – investing with borrowed money.  Using borrowed money and derivatives increases (not decreases) risk, which can lead to both spectacular gains and spectacular losses.

The average life span of a hedge fund is approximately 5 years.  By the five-year point, most hedge funds have either failed (lost most or all of their money), or closed down.

Hedge funds tend to fail most often within the first 30 months of their existence.  After 30 months they are less likely to fail, but more likely to shut down due to mediocre returns.  As a hedge fund investor, you are screwed either way.  If you invest in new hedge funds you risk losing everything; if you invest in an established fund you probably won’t get the returns you are looking for.  Some say that the way to avoid this minor inconvenience is to invest in a "fund of funds": a single fund composed of a number of hedge funds to reduce risk.

The expected annual return on a “fund of funds” is about 7-8% per year (a 9% return on the funds, minus 1-2% management fees), vastly lower than most investors imagine.  For comparison, a typical balanced mutual fund also returns between 7-8% per year.  Some longstanding balanced mutual funds - such as the Fidelity Balanced Fund, available since 1986 - have returned more than 9% annually.

In 2008, Protégé Partners bet Warren Buffett - the most famous investor of all - that hedge funds would outperform the S&P 500 over a 10-year period, as Buffet himself has done.  In the first year of the bet hedge funds vastly outperformed the S&P (dropping only 24% compared the market drop of 37%).  In the following two years the S&P outperformed the hedge funds.  Time will tell the final result.

If you are looking for safe and steady returns, my advice is to forget about hedge funds. Take the easier route: create a balanced portfolio or buy a balanced mutual fund consisting of about 30-40% quality bonds and 60-70% stocks – the time honored strategy for consistent returns with lowered volatility.

If your primary purpose is to show off that you are rich and have money to burn, invest in a hedge fund and tell all your friends.

If you are keen to risk everything to get rick quick, try poker.

____


"We conclude that hedge funds are far riskier and provide much lower returns than is commonly supposed."

Burton Malkiel and Atanu Saha

____



See also:
Hedge Funds: Risk and Return (the pdf presentation)

____